Why do I shut down under stress?

Hello friends,

When people reach out for relationship help, they often want to improve their communication. They hope that if they can just say things differently, they will be heard and understood. The way we communicate does impact a situation, but our communication style is only the tip of the iceberg–it’s just one piece of the puzzle and there’s a great deal under the surface.

To take a deeper look at what happens when conflict goes awry, we start by going inward to understand what we do under stress. There are two main responses: withdraw or pursue.

Withdrawers tend to shut down, become quiet, and zone out when things heat up. Pursuers get anxious, more vocal and activated when under stress. People generally fall into one bucket or the other. However, different situations can bring out different qualities in us. For example, we might act one way with our parents and differently with a romantic partner.

This month I am going to focus on the withdrawing and next month I will focus on the pursuing patterns. Before diving into specific behaviors, let’s zoom out and look at the big picture of the nervous system. At any given time, the nervous system can be regulated or dysregulated. When it is regulated, we are in a window of tolerance.  It is the mental space where a person can effectively manage stress and emotions. When someone gets outside of their window of tolerance, they either get hyperaroused (pursuer) or hypoaroused (withdrawer).

With hypoarousal the nervous system slows down. In the flight, fight, and freeze response, this is the freeze state. It can look like sleepiness, forgetfulness, quietness, or even dissociation. I picture withdrawers as turtles going into their shells for protection.

As a withdrawer myself, I understand the often involuntary shut down experience. Here are some steps to handle this when it comes up.

  1. Clock it: Once you realize you are getting quiet, at a loss for words, or shutting down; acknowledge it. This can be to yourself, or out loud. “I am shutting down. I must be getting flooded”.

  2. Time out: Bring yourself back to the moment by scanning the room, wiggling your fingers or toes, etc. Then let the other person know you need a break from the conversation. Make a plan to check back in 30 minutes. If you need more space, suggest the next time to check-in. It is your responsibility to follow through on continuing the conversation. This is necessary for the other person to know they are not being dismissed or left alone in their discomfort.

  3. Recalibrate: Practice self-care. What would feel soothing to you? Cuddle with a pet. Listen to some music. Go for a walk. Watch a show.

  4. Try again with a plan: Plan for what will help you stay in your window of tolerance, when you come back to the conversation. Make sure you are not hungry or tired. Try a time limit. Ask if the other person would be willing to go for a walk in 30 minutes where you take a break from the conversation.  

It is important to expand our window of tolerance because that is where our prefrontal cortex can be engaged, which allows us to feel and think simultaneously. This helps us listen with curiosity and have empathy. When we dip into hypoarousal and withdraw our body is trying to protect us. It’s a reasonable survival strategy but it’s ineffective as a relational strategy as it cuts off our ability to communicate well.

If you are a withdrawer and want to work on expanding your window of tolerance, reach out. I am here to help

Previous
Previous

If they could just understand my side…

Next
Next

Is Work Sucking the Life Out of Me?